Major League Baseball’s normal salaries took a dive during the Coronavirus pandemic to their lowest level in nearly a quarter-century, according to a study by The Associated Press.
Washington Nationals pitcher Max Scherzer topped the shortened season’s list at $17.8 million, his income partially protected by a huge signing bonus. That is the lowest amount for baseball’s highest-paid player since Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Kevin Brown made $15.7 million in 2000.
Players receive about 37% of their 2020 pay under the formula agreed to in March by MLB and the union, a figure the union wound up keeping during lengthy bitter negotiations that failed to produce an agreement. Commissioner Rob Manfred unilaterally announced a 60-game regular-season schedule that started four months late on July 23, down from the normal 162 games for each team.
Salaries averaged $1,295,942 on expanded Opening Day rosters after prorated pay was factored in, according to the AP study. That must feel like a throwback paycheck, similar to a vintage jersey — it’s the lowest average in the AP’s annual Opening Day study since $1,176,967 in 1996 and down from $4,375,486 at the start of the 2019 season.
Unhappy with flattening salaries during the first four years of a collective bargaining agreement that runs to December 2021, players spoke up even before the season about seeking large changes. Talks figure to be the most contentious since the 1994-95 strike, the last shortened seasons before this one.
Even with contracts at full value and projected for 25-man active rosters, this year’s average of $4,520,010 would have represented just a 3.1% increase over 2016’s $4,381,980.
Part of the drop in the average was caused by roster expansion to an active limit of 30 per team at the season’s start, adding more major leaguers making the $563,500 minimum or close to it. There were 1,007 players on Opening Day rosters and injured lists, up from 878 last year.
Scherzer’s $210 million, 7-year contract includes a $50 million signing bonus — baseball signing bonuses are distinct from salaries and not subject to reduction. His $35 million salary, which is entirely deferred, was sliced to $12.96 million.
MLB’s initial proposal in late May would have cut the highest-paid stars the most, and Scherzer’s 2020 salary would have been reduced to about $4.85 million. The union fought hard to keep the prorated pay in the March deal, while MLB argued it needed additional cuts to play in empty ballparks. As a result, MLB called for the shortest schedule since 1878.
Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Clayton Kershaw was second on the Opening Day list at $16.3 million, boosted by a $23 million signing bonus.
Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mike Trout was third at $15.8 million, followed by San Diego shortstop Manny Machado ($15.1 million), Houston pitcher Zack Greinke ($14.1 million), New York Yankees pitcher Gerrit Cole ($13.3 million), Colorado third baseman Nolan Arenado ($12.96 million), Houston second baseman Jose Altuve ($12.63 million), Astros pitcher Justin Verlander ($12 million) and Nationals pitcher Stephen Strasburg ($11.7 million).
Each player’s figure includes his adjusted 2020 salary plus a prorated share of his signing bonus. For players such as Scherzer, parts of salaries deferred without interest are discounted to present-day value. The player pool includes Minnesota pitcher Michael Pineda, who has a guaranteed contract and started the season on the restricted list while completing a suspension for a banned diuretic.
Before the pandemic, Trout was set to top the 2020 list at $38.5 million, followed by Cole ($36 million), Scherzer ($35.9 million), Arenado ($35 million), Machado ($34 million), Verlander ($33 million), Greinke ($32.9 million), Dodgers pitcher David Price ($32 million), Strasburg ($31.6 million) and Kershaw ($31 million).
This year’s average would rise to $1,610,087 if the two lowest-paid players on each team were dropped and $1,704,810 if the lowest four were left off, which would leave teams with the originally intended active limit of 26. By cutting another player and getting down to the old active limit of 25, the average would rise to $1,757,121.
At full value and without prorating, this year’s average would have been $3,931,025.
It would have projected to $4,144,328 with an active limit of 28 and $4,386,353 at 26, which would have been up 0.2% from last year’s AP study average of $4,375,486. Had active rosters remained at 25, it would have projected to $4.52 million, a 3.3% increase over 2019.
Even though MLB players 2020 salaries are prorated for 60-games, based on a 162 game season, they’re still making as much money as most average Americans, and should have nothing to complain about right now.